Money, explained for the rest of us.

Get our free daily email →

Servicers must give 45 days’ notice before charging for force-placed insurance

By

Image Credit: Mikhail Nilov - Pexels License/Pexels

Mortgage servicers have to give homeowners 45 days’ notice before they can charge for force-placed insurance, the policy a servicer buys when it believes a borrower’s own coverage has lapsed. Once a homeowner sends proof of coverage, the servicer has 15 days to cancel the policy and refund the premiums for any period the two overlapped, under a federal rule known as Regulation X.

The rule matters most at renewal time, when a cancelled or non-renewed home policy can leave a mortgage file looking uninsured. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says force-placed coverage is usually more expensive than a policy the homeowner finds directly.

The two warnings a servicer must send

Under 12 CFR 1024.37, a servicer may not charge a borrower for force-placed insurance unless it has a reasonable basis to believe the borrower failed to keep the insurance the loan requires. Even then, the first written notice has to be delivered or mailed at least 45 days before the charge.

A reminder notice follows. It cannot go out until at least 30 days after the first notice, and it must be delivered or mailed at least 15 days before the servicer assesses a premium or fee. A servicer can charge only if no proof of continuous coverage arrives by the end of the 15-day period that begins when the reminder is delivered or mailed. The notices must state that hazard insurance is required on the property, give the servicer’s contact information and state the cost of the insurance as an annual premium.

The same rule requires that any charge be bona fide and reasonable, meaning it must bear a reasonable relationship to the servicer’s cost of providing the service.

Anyone who has received a notice from a mortgage servicer about insurance should read it for the date the charge can start. Sending proof of coverage before that date is how a homeowner can head off the charge.

Proof of coverage starts a 15-day clock

Homeowners who already have coverage in place, or who get a new policy after a lapse, can send proof to the servicer. The CFPB’s official commentary says a servicer may ask for a copy of the declarations page, the insurance certificate, the policy itself or similar written confirmation. A servicer may reject evidence if the insurer or agent will not confirm it or the policy does not meet the loan contract’s requirements.

Within 15 days of receiving proof that the borrower had qualifying coverage in place, the servicer must cancel the force-placed policy. It must also refund all force-placed premium charges and related fees the borrower paid for any period of overlapping coverage, and remove those charges from the account. The CFPB defines overlapping coverage as the time when both policies were in effect at once. A homeowner who replaces a cancelled policy after the servicer has already bought coverage can end up in that overlap, and the refund covers the related fees too, not only the premium.

Why the premium can sting

The CFPB’s consumer page on force-placed insurance says a servicer may require it when a borrower has no policy of their own. In many cases, the CFPB says, this insurance protects only the lender, not the homeowner. It adds that force-placed insurance is usually more expensive than a policy the homeowner finds.

In an August 2023 consumer advisory, the CFPB said the cost of force-placed coverage can be twice what a homeowner would normally pay for insurance, and that for some properties the increase could be $100 a month or more. The advisory said a force-placed policy usually protects only the lender.

What homeowners can do after a lapse

The CFPB’s advice is to get an insurance policy or reinstate the old one, send proof to the servicer and ask it to cancel the force-placed policy. A homeowner who disagrees with what the servicer did can send a notice of error. The CFPB says complaints can be filed online or by calling (855) 411-CFPB (2372).

The 2023 advisory also covers the step before a lapse. It says an insurer should notify a homeowner if it decides not to renew, and that the insurer might reverse a decision and renew. It tells homeowners to ask why coverage is ending and to shop for a policy that meets the mortgage’s requirements, checking with the state insurance department for approved insurers.

If private coverage is hard to find, the advisory points to a state FAIR plan, which it says typically costs more than a standard policy. Once the homeowner has a policy, the advisory says, the servicer should be told, and the homeowner has the right to remove force-placed insurance.

Renewals carry their own paperwork. Under the rule, a servicer must send a renewal notice at least 45 days before a charge for renewing or replacing force-placed insurance, and it does not have to send that written notice more than once a year.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.


Spotted an error? Tell us at [email protected]. We fix mistakes fast and in the open — see how we work on our standards page.